Replacing an old door, start to finish

Garage door replacement in Arlington Heights, IL

Some doors reach a point where one more spring or another patched section just keeps the problem on the house. Garage door replacement in Arlington Heights pulls the old panels, springs, cables, tracks and seals off the opening and puts a full new system in their place. To talk through whether that is your door, call (847) 440-3650.

Garage door replacement in Arlington Heights: a faded, dented almond door with a torn bottom seal on a 1960s brick ranch.

What does a full replacement actually cover?

Measuring an empty garage door opening with a tape measure and a level before a garage door replacement.

A garage door is a coupled system: panels, torsion tube, springs, cables, drums, rollers, hinges, tracks, seals and the opener. A full swap addresses the whole assembly at once. The steps below are what our technician does on the visit, not steps for a homeowner.

1. Checking the opening, jambs and header

We start with a tape and a level. Wood jambs need to be plumb and thick enough to hold new track brackets. The header must be square and solid, since it carries the opener rail and the torsion tube. Soft, split or rotted wood gets called out before any new door goes in.

2. Taking the old door down safely

Even with an old door resting on the floor, its torsion springs and lift cables carry most of their load. That is why a spring that snaps while the door is closed leaves a door that will not lift: the springs pass their lift to the door through the cables, and once a spring is gone there is nothing to raise the panels. Our technician handles the spring, drum, cable and bottom-bracket work, and the sections then come out from the top down, roller by roller, with the vertical and horizontal track unbolted from the jambs and ceiling. Do not pull the emergency release rope, touch the winding cones or reach for the bottom brackets until we have said the tension is off. Ask about removal of the old door when you call.

3. New tracks, springs and cables sized to the new door

Every door gets track cut for its height and headroom, springs wound for its weight, and cables cut for its drop. Old track rarely lines up with fresh brackets, and old springs were sized for a different panel anyway. Fresh rollers go in as the sections stack.

4. Weather seals and the bottom seal

A new bottom astragal fits to the sill so the door lands on a fresh rubber lip. Perimeter seals go along both jambs and across the top. On an unheated garage this separates a door that keeps out the wind from one that whistles at every gust.

5. Reconnecting or replacing the opener

If the opener runs quietly and its sensors work, we mount the new door on it and reset the travel and force for the new weight. If it is worn, or the head has no safety sensors at the bottom of each track, we talk over a new opener if the old one is worn. We make that call at the door, with the old opener still on its brackets.

6. Balance check and safety reversal

Once the door is up, our technician disconnects the opener arm and lifts the door by hand. A balanced door stops wherever we let it. The opener then goes back on, a full cycle runs, and we test the safety reverse using the photo eyes and a block on the floor.

Old rusted garage door section beside a new white replacement section with corner pads, leaning on a brick wall.

Signs the door is done

Symptom Likely cause What it usually needs
Cracked or dented panels across two or more sections Impact, or metal fatigue in an aging door Full replacement; matching a discontinued panel is rarely possible
Rotted wood on a wood or composite door Water sitting at the bottom rail and jambs Full replacement; wood past a point cannot be patched cleanly
A section is fine but its pattern was dropped Original design no longer in production Full replacement rather than a mismatched patch
Repeat spring failures on the same door Undersized springs, or a bent shaft carried forward for years New door with correctly sized springs and a straight shaft
Door will not hold balance after a fresh repair Bowed sections, tired hinges, or a warped track Replacement to reset the whole system at once
Old opener with no photo eyes at the tracks External entrapment protection missing New opener alongside the door

Keeping the door, or starting over

This is the hardest call on a garage door, and cost often decides it. Our post on how to decide walks through the trade-offs at length.

When we repair it

We repair when the door itself is straight and sound, the panels look right, and one part has failed. A snapped spring on a door that is otherwise level and balanced is a repair. A worn opener on a good door is a repair. A single dented section on a modern steel door often gets replacing one section instead, rather than a full swap.

When we suggest a new door

We suggest replacement when the panels are the problem, when small repairs stack on small repairs, or when parts are no longer made. Fresh hardware on failing panels does not get the panels back, and the door still looks worn once the work is done.

At the door, we tell you which side you are on.

Keep the door, or start over

A straight door with one failure holds; a door with worn parts across the board asks for a swap.

Repair

  • The door is straight and one part has failed
  • Panels, hinges and tracks are still sound
  • Matched parts are still made for the model

A new door

  • Panels are cracked through or rusted from inside
  • Small repairs keep stacking in a single year
  • Springs, cables, rollers and seal are tired together

A note on townhouse and condo doors

In a townhouse or condo, the door face can be covered by the association's rules, while the opener and interior hardware stay with the homeowner. Read the association's guidelines before picking a door, or ask the board for pre-approval, so the new one does not have to come back off.

Parts a full swap needs

Almost every replacement gets new panels, a fresh torsion tube, matched springs wound to the new door's weight, lift cables cut to the drop, drums, rollers, hinges, bottom brackets, vertical and horizontal track, a bottom seal and perimeter seals. What can sometimes stay: a recent opener with working safety sensors, the framing (if the jambs and header are still straight and solid), and the exterior trim.

Old springs never carry over onto a new door. Spring life is counted in open-and-close cycles, and a spring that spent its life on the previous door is not sized for the new one either. For choosing the new door, the installation page walks through materials, insulation and panel styles.

From your call to a working door

  1. The call. Say what the door is doing, roughly how old it looks, and what brand is on the opener if you can read it from a few feet back. Ring (847) 440-3650.
  2. The look. Our technician measures the opening, checks the springs, cables and header, and works out whether the door is worth another repair or ready for a swap.
  3. The work and the tests. We remove the old door, install the new one, balance it, and run the safety reverse and the photo-eye check.

Older housing here and what changes on a swap

Half of the village's houses were built before 1974,1 and only about 9 percent went up in 2000 or later.2 Ceiling clearance in older attached garages can fall short of what a standard rail assumes, which pushes the choice toward a wall-mount opener or a low-headroom track kit. Our note on original doors on older homes covers what else can show up on the visit.

Village housing age by decade

About 44 percent of the village's units were built in the 1960s and 1970s; about 9 percent in 2000 or later.

Garage door replacement in Arlington Heights: your questions

Can I keep my opener when the door is replaced?

Sometimes. An opener with a quiet motor and working photo eyes can run the new door once travel and force are reset for the weight. An older head with no sensors, or one that groans on the current door, is worth swapping at the same visit.

Do the tracks and springs get replaced with the door?

Yes. Track is cut for the new door's height and headroom, and the springs are wound for its weight. Old track rarely lines up with a new set of brackets, and springs from the previous door are already partway through their cycle life.

What happens to the old door?

Ask about removal of the old door when you call.

Is a village permit needed for a door swap?

The Village's own residential permit checklist covers detached garages, garage-only re-roofs and detached garage demolition, without a stand-alone item for a garage door swap.3 For a firm answer on your address, the Building and Life Safety office at Village Hall can tell you what your specific project needs. Our post on permits for a replacement has the fuller picture.

My association has rules on doors: what should I check?

Look up the design guidelines before picking a door and read what they cover. If the guidelines are silent, ask the board for a written approval before the order goes in.

How long does a replacement take?

The length depends on the door, the opener and any framing work.

What drives the price of a replacement?

The door itself is the biggest lever: single or double, steel versus wood, insulated versus not, window inserts and any non-stock color. After that, the size and condition of the opening matters, and whether the opener stays or gets swapped. Our post on what sets a replacement price walks through each factor.

Do not keep running a door that keeps failing. If a spring lets go or a panel folds, stop pressing the button and keep vehicles and people out from under the opening. Stay clear of the springs, cables, brackets and the opener head until we get there. Phone (847) 440-3650 with the door's rough age, what has failed, and whether the opener is coming with it.

New white raised-panel garage door after a garage door replacement, closed, on a brick ranch house.

Garage door acting up?

Tell us what the door is doing. A person picks up and asks the right questions.

Call (847) 440-3650

Mon to Sat 7am to 7pm · Sun 9am to 5pm

Browse all services

Rather we call you?

Leave your name and number and we will call you back.

We use your number only to call you back. Privacy policy